2011년 4월 25일 월요일

Synthesis Essay 2nd draft


Do We Really Want Well-packaged Students?
– About the Korean Education System
  
On March of 2009, Barack Obama, the president of the Unites States, the world’s symbolic nation of freedom and wealth, surprised Koreans.[1] During his speech, Mr. President very positively described the education system of South Korea. Obama asserted that “our children spend over a month less in school than children in South Korea every year. That’s no way to prepare them for a 21st-century economy … If they can do that in South Korea, we can do it right here in the United States of America.” Nevertheless, Koreans were rather perplexed than proud. Having been one of the hottest potatoes in Korean society, Korean education system is usually condemned, rather than complimented. Many American educators and columnists reacted sourly to their president’s speech. Mitch Albom, the bestselling author of the US, critically presented the reality of Korean education during a visit where he toured Korean schools, writing in an article that “we can't do what they're doing here. Because we don't believe in it.”[2] Korean education may seem qualified for its massive quantity. Nevertheless, the Korean system fails to heighten the fundamental quality of education by emphasizing the quantity rather quality, not recognizing the various types of ability of students, and not being able to satisfy their own customers-students.


    
The tight education system of Korea is quite demanding and requires students to sit in class for a long time. Though Obama has applauded this very point of the Korean education system, it is actually very ineffective. As Mitch Albom describes, Korean school is “like a full-time job plus a full-time marriage.” Comparing the high school timetable of various countries, we can see that Korean students spend most of their time at school unlike their counterparts in the US, China, Japan, and France.[3] Korean students thus have less time to learn about the world outside of their text books. On the other hand, students of other countries have more time to explore the real world and enjoy the beauty of life. To give a specific example, French elementary students do not have classes on Wednesday. Even high school students only have morning classes. They are encouraged to use this free time to enjoy cultural experiences such as visiting exhibitions or watching art performances. French museums and theatres promote this by offering reduced rates for teenagers on Wednesday. While other juveniles have balanced experiences from both text books and the real world, Korean teenagers spend their valuable time locked up in their schools from morning until night. Are Korean students will be more apt to deal with problems in their lives better than their counterparts in other countries, just because they know a couple of more mathematical formulas? Will Korean teenagers learn how to enjoy their lives and respect themselves from the mounts of workbooks with red markings on them?


 
Despite many criticisms toward Korean education, some people, including Obama, still insist that the high scores of Korean students in standardized tests prove the superiority of Korean education. It is true that Korea ranked second highest among developed countries in the PISA(Program for International Student Assessment). However, this does not mean that students are served with qualified education which suits their unique characteristics. Korean students are packed in a classroom with thirty to forty other students to learn subjects such as math, language, science, and history. A student is solely judged by his or her academic ability in these “major subjects”. Whilst there is a possibility that this student is superb in art, music, dancing, or running, Korean education ignores the seed of potential inside of students. The famous theory of multiple intelligence and its founder Howard Gardner, however, state that people have different types of intelligence such as linguistic, logical-mathematical, special, interpersonal, intrapersonal, naturalistic intelligence, musical, and bodily-kinesthetic.[4] Whereas many countries are now trying to get away from the tradition of focusing on linguistic and logical intelligence, Korea is still attached to the old custom. According to Gardner, now a professor at Harvard University, students are better served by a broader vision of education, wherein teachers use different methodologies and activities to reach all students, not only those who excel at linguistic and logical intelligence. Korean education is certainly not an ideal model of education system since it does not help students to find their unique aptitudes and develop them. What is the use of education if it cannot answer to a person asking “How do we best take advantage of the uniqueness conferred on us as a species exhibiting several intelligences?”[5]




Most importantly, students themselves are not satisfied with the Korean education system. They study, study, and study but say that they do not learn much from school. The purpose of high school education has degenerated into merely a tool to get into a college rather than a carefully instructed process of self-discovery of young students. It is not too much to say that the fate of a Korean student is decided by the Sooneung(Korean type of SAT), which is held only once in a year. Isn’t it so unfair and cruel to demand students to decide their destiny by a “one-shot-one-deal” test, especially when they have so much undiscovered potential to do anything and be anyone they want?[6] Do Korean students really feel happy with this situation? It seems not, since there are numerous satires on Korean education made by the students themselves. When we buy or sell a product, we do not call it a “good product” if it does not fit into the tastes of most customers. It is a “failed product” since it cannot carry out its mission to satisfy. If a country’s education system arouses so many complaints and hardship from the students forced to endure it, it is definitely not a “good education system”.

Education is the most important thing to many students since it massively affects them during their whole life. Human beings have “educated” their descendants for hundreds and thousands of years, yet it seems that the definition of “good” education is still a controversial issue. Nevertheless, we can also say that these years of trial and error with education have led us to grasp what is a potentially good education system time after time. As the above evidences have already revealed, the current Korean education system is certainly not an ideal role model, though Obama thought it was. Since we know what the problems are, we hope Korean education will progress further with the flow of history.

댓글 없음:

댓글 쓰기